TRP Ep 7: “The Bot Did It!” — The AI Excuse That Didn’t Fly in Court

Remember back in engineering college when a group project went completely off the rails, and that one teammate stood in front of the external examiner and said, “Sir, woh wala module toh usne banaya tha, mujhe kuch nahi pata”? Shifting blame when things go wrong is an age-old human instinct.
Now imagine a massive international airline standing inside a courtroom and using that exact same excuse—except instead of blaming a lazy teammate, they tried to blame their own customer service chatbot as if it were an independent human being!
Welcome to the landmark case of AI chatbot legal liability (Moffatt v. Air Canada), a documented legal showdown that permanently changed how corporations are held responsible for what their automated bots say online.
The story began in November 2022 when a Canadian passenger named Jake Moffatt needed to book an urgent flight from Vancouver to Toronto following the death of his grandmother. Grief-stricken and looking for bereavement fare discounts, he turned to the official on Air Canada chatbot on it’s website.
Though the Air Canada chatbot was polite, helpful, and completely wrong. It assured him that he could purchase a regular ticket immediately and apply for a retroactive bereavement refund within 90 days of ticket issuance. Trusting the airline’s official digital assistant, he booked the flight and saved a screenshot of the chat.
“The Air Canada Chatbot Did It, Not Us!”
When Moffatt submitted his refund claim weeks later, Air Canada flatly rejected it. Their actual policy stated that bereavement fares could never be claimed after a flight was purchased. Even after an airline representative admitted in an email that the chatbot had given “misleading words,” the company refused to pay the difference.
So, Moffatt took Air Canada to British Columbia’s Civil Resolution Tribunal. What happened next sounded like a comedy scene straight out of Oh My God!—Air Canada’s legal team formally argued that the airline should not be held liable because its chatbot was a “separate legal entity that is responsible for its own actions”. They claimed the passenger should have ignored the bot and double-checked the static policy webpage linked inside the chat.
Tribunal member Christopher Rivers was not buying it. Calling Air Canada’s defense a “remarkable submission,” he ruled firmly against the airline and ordered them to pay C$812.02 in damages, interest, and tribunal fees. The ruling stated clearly that a chatbot is simply part of a company’s website, and customers have no obligation to double-check one part of a company’s site against another.
Check out other posts around AI
Why AI Chatbot Legal Liability Demands Better Digital Governance
While the payout was modest, the legal ripple effect of AI chatbot legal liability has echoed across boardrooms worldwide. That single tribunal ruling officially killed the “the AI hallucinated, not us” defense for enterprises.
For founders, agency owners, and digital leaders, the takeaway is simple: when an AI assistant sits on your website or WhatsApp channel, it is legally speaking on your behalf. Keeping it tied to verified company documents and routing tricky refund or policy calls to a real human keeps your customer support fast without signing checks your business never intended to cash.
Sources
- Civil Resolution Tribunal of British Columbia: Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149
https://decisions.civilresolutionbc.ca/crt/crtd/en/item/525448/index.do - American Bar Association: BC Tribunal Confirms Companies Remain Liable for Information Provided by AI Chatbot
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/business_law/resources/business-law-today/2024-february/bc-tribunal-confirms-companies-remain-liable-information-provided-ai-chatbot/ - BBC News: Airline Held Liable for Its Chatbot Giving Passenger Bad Advice
https://www.bbc.com/news/travel-68378350


